In a stunning turn of events, the EJ Whitten Medal for Victoria’s best player in the 2026 AFL Origin game was awarded to Lachie Ash of the GWS Giants. But here’s where it gets controversial: our player ratings had four stars ranked higher than him. Could the judges have missed something? Let’s dive into the details and see if you agree with the decision.
The highly anticipated 2026 AFL Origin clash between Victoria and Western Australia showcased some of the biggest names in footy, and Foxfooty.com.au was there to rate every Victorian player out of 10. And this is the part most people miss: while Lachie Ash’s performance was solid, others clearly stood out more on the day. But before we get into that, don’t forget to catch all the action from the 2026 AFL Pre-season AAMI Community Series LIVE and ad-break free on FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1.
Opening Round Highlights
Before we dissect the player ratings, a quick reminder: gambling can have serious consequences. Set a deposit limit and seek help if needed. For free and confidential support, call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.
Player Ratings Breakdown
Toby Greene (GWS Giants) – 8
A constant menace, Greene popped up at crucial moments, setting up scores and kicking two goals himself from 18 touches and 11 marks. His ability to influence the game was undeniable.Jack Sinclair (St Kilda) – 4
Sinclair struggled to make his usual impact off half-back, a surprising performance from a player known for his reliability.Caleb Serong (Fremantle) – 6
Serong proved he belongs on the big stage with a strong first quarter, setting up scores and snapping a crucial goal late in the game to secure Victoria’s win.Marcus Bontempelli (Western Bulldogs) – 8
As captain, Bontempelli led by example, dominating with 30 touches, 10 marks, and eight inside 50s. His ability to set up teammates was a game-changer, though some might argue he deserved the EJ Whitten Medal over Ash. What do you think?Hugh McCluggage (Brisbane Lions) – 7
McCluggage started strong with two first-half goals but faded after half-time, leaving fans wanting more.Zach Merrett (Essendon) – 7
Merrett silenced critics with a strong first quarter, kicking a goal and making nine disposals. Despite slowing down later, his late goal capped a solid performance. Could he have been overlooked for the medal?Nick Daicos (Collingwood) – 8
Daicos thrived under pressure, delivering 38 disposals, nine marks, and seven clearances. His intercept to set up Bontempelli’s goal was a highlight, but was his overall impact greater than Ash’s?Zak Butters (Port Adelaide) – 8
Butters was Victoria’s spark, always in the thick of the action with 27 touches and seven inside 50s. His race for a new contract will be one of 2026’s biggest stories.Sam Darcy (Western Bulldogs) – 4
Highly hyped, Darcy struggled to make an impact, finishing with just 0.2 goals. A disappointing outing for the young star.Max Gawn (Melbourne) – 5
Gawn wasn’t as dominant as expected, battling Darcy Cameron for much of the game. The new ruck rules will be an interesting test for him.Lachie Ash (GWS Giants) – 7
While Ash’s 25 disposals, nine intercepts, and seven score involvements were impressive, was it enough to justify the EJ Whitten Medal? His epic run in the last quarter was a highlight, but four players on our list outshone him. What’s your take?
Injury Update
Carlton’s Jacob Weitering was stretchered off after a brutal collision, a stark reminder of the game’s physical toll.
Final Thoughts
The 2026 AFL Origin game was a showcase of talent, but the EJ Whitten Medal decision has sparked debate. Did Lachie Ash truly deserve it, or were players like Bontempelli or Daicos overlooked? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—this is one discussion you won’t want to miss!
